Sponsors

A Golden Age of Satire Email Print

The proverbial Chinese curse, "May You Live in Interesting Times" (which a quick google-about reveals, is most likely not of Chinese origin at all) is something that many of us here can certainly relate to the past five years of American history.  I would suggest that a corollary to this notion, that "interesting" times may not be the most desirable of times in which to live, would be that they are also great fodder for satire, possessing as both imperial Rome did and early 21st Century America does an overabundance of absurdity.  And it seems to me that due to a confluence of cultural forces, we are fortunate to be living in an age that has provided great and willing satirists and purveyors of ironic humor.

I doubt I am alone in having noted that there is something horribly askew when one can argue that our best newspaper is a fake newspaper (The Onion) and our best news show is a fake news show (The Daily Show), both of which have been enormously successful, and the latter of which has spawned a best selling book and now a spinoff show, The Colbert Report, that consists almost entirely of that most familiar of satirical forms, parody (and which even has its own website).

Although the idea for this post has long been tickling the edges of my subconscious, it crystallized this morning on reading two very different things, the first this brilliant Calvin Trillin poem that BiPM had on C&J:

When shells fall close and smoke is thick,
Real tough guys never run. They stick.
Or so says Five Deferments Dick.

No wavering---no he's a brick.
To cut and run would make him sick.
Or so says Five Deferments Dick.

Appeasers cannot take a lick,
But tough guys bite and gouge and kick.
Or so says Five Deferments Dick.

and the second, Atrios's citation of a Village Voice article describing the upcoming Showtime movie "Homecoming."

"This is a horror story because most of the characters are Republicans," director Joe Dante announced before the November 13 world premiere of his latest movie, Homecoming, at the Turin Film Festival. Republicans, as it happens, will be the ones who find Homecoming's agitprop premise scariest: In an election year, dead veterans of the current conflict crawl out of their graves and stagger single-mindedly to voting booths so they can eject the president who sent them to fight a war sold on "horseshit and elbow grease."
The dizzying high point of Showtime's new Masters of Horror series, the hour-long Homecoming (which premieres December 2) is easily one of the most important political films of the Bush II era. With its only slightly caricatured right-wingers, the film nails the casual fraudulence and contortionist rhetoric that are the signatures of the Bush-Cheney administration.
 [Much more on it at the links for those interested.]

How broad a spectrum does satire cover?  Who else can we include among its greatest practitioners?  Well we have cartoonists ranging from Tom Tomorrow to Tom Toles to the undermentioned and utterly brilliant two part "The Great Go-Goop War" by Tom Chalkey (part one and part two).  But we also have works of "high" satire (though who can tell the difference anymore?) such as Tony Kushner's transcendent Only We Who Guard The Mystery Shall Be Unhappy, a one-act play riffing off of Dostoevsky's "Grand Inquisitor" in which Laura Bush is confronted by the ghosts of dead Iraqi children.  (If you haven't seen either the Chalkey or Kushner go. read. them. now.)

The blogosphere (and internet more generally) have proven a perfect medium for satire and direct parody, from works of pure parody like The General and whitehouse.org to those who like to dabble in satire, such as Billmon and the the Poorman.  A quick look at just the nominees list from the most recent Koufax awards (both most humorous post and most humorous blog) can take hours to get through.  The urge to satire and ironic humor is everywhere online (heck, even yours truly tries his poor hand at it every once in a while).  Just read through any Eschaton comment thread -- heck they even have their own brilliant parody troll, the, um, sublime Merkin Patriot.

All of which to say is that I've undoubtedly failed to mention dozens of your favorite humorists and satirists, and so I'll open the floor to those that you find the funniest and the most biting (and are these always the same thing).  (I'd also be interested in hearing other folks' thoughts on the hows and whys of flourishing satire.)

What say you?

-- Stu


KEYWORDS: ,

Sign up for a Complimentary Member Account... Join the community! It's fast. And it'll allow you to take advantage of all this site's great features!

< This I Believe | Media Reaction to Bush's 'New' Iraq Speech >
 Display:
personally, I live by the onion and jon stewart. but I find most blog and web satire poorly done, with a few notable exceptions. I also find it hard to get anyone's attention with satire, but then, maybe that's because I write a satirical blog that almost nobody reads.

it's at http://witlist.blogspot.com (to be completely self serving). check it out, and check out my new page on the cortex, where I'll be cross posting from time to time. and let me know what you think.

cheers,

dt

by Witlist on 11/30/2005 11:52:08 PM EST

In the winter of 2000, I was freelancing for a local entertainment/comedy publication in Richmond,VA, and they had me interviewing this band, Lake Trout. I asked the drummer where he saw art (in the general sense - music, film, visual, etc.) going in this country for the new millenium, and he made the comment that since Bush was going to be president, it would bode well for art. If I remember correctly his exact answer went along the lines of, "with the coming period of repression, I think we'll see alot of genuis stuff coming out."

If you don't understand someone, consider that the shortcoming may not lie with that person, but rather with your own understanding.

by Aethern on 12/01/2005 08:14:45 AM EST

Tom Burka, although he's posting rarely and sporadically these days. I only found the site about a year ago and I had a great couple of days going back through his archives.

I think Hunter at DKos is one of the best. I actually have permanently hotlisted his Liberal Blog Crisis: Snark Shortage diary (this was long before he was a front-pager).

by SusanG on 12/01/2005 03:38:22 PM EST

Hunter is incredibly talented; he definitely belongs up there.

-- Stu

by sdf on 12/02/2005 11:06:27 AM EST

[ Parent ]
Don't know how I missed this post...

Anyway, I'm currently taking a class called "Fake News, Politics and Popular Culture," examining why and how things like The Daily Show work. We also had a field trip to the Colbert show. Pretty cool.

I have actually found that the blogosphere doesn't take well to humor. Maybe there's just not that many talented satirists (beyond the ones you've described), but I've seen both at dkos and tpmcafe lots of satire tried, and it's mostly received with blank stares at best.

Even smart-aleck comments are rated down.

I know that my attempt at humor has been sitting in the Submission Q here for a while now.

Ahem Ahem.

Well, maybe I'm just not that funny.

(My fiance laughed at my post. But then again, she loves me.)

Dissent Protects Democracy

by cscs on 12/02/2005 03:44:40 PM EST

 Display: