Is it about to be blown open? Email Print

This from Editor & Publisher.

NEW YORK Ever since the Democrats briefly closed the U.S. Senate from view earlier this week, to protest alleged Republican foot-dragging in probing Bush administration pre-war manipulation of intelligence, the press has been asking: So what new evidence do the Democrats have in this matter?

Tomorrow, The New York Times starts to answer the question, with reporter Doug Jehl disclosing the contents of a newly declassified memo apparently passed to him by Sen. Carl Levin of Michigan, the top Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee.

It shows that an al-Qaeda official in American custody was identified as a likely fabricator months before the Bush administration began to use his statements as the foundation for its claims that Iraq trained al-Qaeda members to use biological and chemical weapons, according to this Defense Intelligence Agency document from February 2002.

It declared that it was probable that the prisoner, Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi, "was intentionally misleading the debriefers" in making claims about Iraqi support for al-Qaeda's work with illicit weapons, Jehl reports.

"The document provides the earliest and strongest indication of doubts voiced by American intelligence agencies about Mr. Libi's credibility," Jehl writes. "Without mentioning him by name, President Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney, Colin L. Powell, then secretary of state, and other administration officials repeatedly cited Mr. Libi's information as `credible' evidence that Iraq was training Al Qaeda members in the use of explosives and illicit weapons.

I have wondered what inforamtion the Dems had to shut th Ruthugs up about their oversight responsibility and what made them shut the doors.

This could be VERY big. I await the NYT series on this.

Our job? To make it VERY clear and easy to understand.

Update [2005-11-5 18:24:56 by NYBri]: The actual NYTimes article is now up.  Interesting read. Interesting last item:

Mr. Libi remains in custody, apparently at in Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, where he was sent in 2003, according to government officials.

KEYWORDS:

Sign up for a Complimentary Member Account... Join the community! It's fast. And it'll allow you to take advantage of all this site's great features!

< Massachusetts to End Gerrymandering? | The Elephant and the Race Card >
 Display:
...that I have transferred. Here are two comments from that thread, that I've deleted:

--------------------------- --

Tomorrow's round of Sunday talk

Should be considerably enlivened by this piece.

With Spector agreenting to hold off the Alito hearings until January, we have a two month window to drive home the distortions, exagerations, and outright lies involved in taking us to Iraq.  If the dam continues to crack the way it has over the last few weeks, and Harry Reid keeps the pressure on, Bush is going to be serving crow instead of turkey this Thanksgiving.

by Devilstower on 11/05/2005 06:12:48 PM EST

--------------------------- -----------

Boy, do I feel silly

who'd a thunk it that there was a need for MORE information than we already had to justify closing the Senate doors due to the lies that started the Iraq war?

by causa on 11/05/2005 06:13:26 PM EST

The Albany Project. The best damned blog about New York State politics.

by NYBri on 11/05/2005 06:28:26 PM EST

This is what I was pondering reading the E&P story, waiting for the NYT to post. Having read it, I don't  think so. At least not on the basis of this one story alone. Levin handed them the stuff.

Anyway, that's only background to the real stuff. But I can't help but think that had they been doing their job in the run-up to this debacle and not actually had forwarded it all with goddamned July Miller peddling the big lies, we wouldn't be where we are right now. Including in the middle of a second Bush term.

I'm just a little bit bitter.

by mcjoan on 11/05/2005 06:43:57 PM EST

...Yes, this is background. I'm waiting fot eh emails from Cheney, et al, saying to play up the bogus info and put it in speaches and get Judas Miller to write about it...

This is all unravelling so fast, it's hard to keep up.  I"m off to do some more snooping.

The Albany Project. The best damned blog about New York State politics.

by NYBri on 11/05/2005 06:52:07 PM EST

[ Parent ]
I hope it's more than just this memo that the Ds have to raise some hell with.

BTW, see how Chalabi is going to be in town next week? He's already got his appointment with Rice set up.

Bastards.

by mcjoan on 11/05/2005 06:55:06 PM EST

[ Parent ]
So, in the same week, we get liars named "Libi" and "Libby."  Should we expect more variants?  Perhaps "Lieby?"

I wonder if Bush gave this guy a cute nickname before they hid him down at Guantánamo.

by Devilstower on 11/05/2005 07:54:11 PM EST

Al Qaeda-Iraq Link Recanted

also see Wikipedia

In fact, see Wiki first, then WaPo.  That's how I connected.

All it takes to fly is to hurl yourself at the ground... and miss. (Douglas Adams)

by scoophound on 11/05/2005 08:13:47 PM EST

Now, wonder if the NYT has connected Libi to Judy?  Wonder if they'll connect any dots for us, or we'll have to do it?

You're right about this. I'm sure Durbin and Reid have more. Given a closed session and all, they'll have to be careful about what comes to light.

But I've got some extra batteries for your flashlight, if you need any.

Taxes shall be levied according to ability to pay. That is the only American principle. FDR

by btyarbro on 11/05/2005 08:25:36 PM EST

This is old news.  WaPo had it 8/1/2004-link is above-

Wikipedia has more links - link above. Says it was first reported by NBC in 1994.

I just got the 1/6/02 full NYT story about his capture.  I'll post it in a minute.

All it takes to fly is to hurl yourself at the ground... and miss. (Douglas Adams)

by scoophound on 11/05/2005 08:37:54 PM EST

[ Parent ]
First of all, NBC first had the story 1/4/02 (not 1994)

This is NYT on 1/6/02.

NATION CHALLENGED: THE HUNTED; U.S. Takes Custody Of a Qaeda Trainer Seized by Pakistan
By  ERIC SCHMITT with ERIK ECKHOLM

The United States has taken custody of one of Osama bin Laden's top paramilitary trainers, the most senior member of Al Qaeda seized in the three-month war in Afghanistan, American officials said today.

The capture marks a potential intelligence boon for American officials in their hunt for Mr. bin Laden and their quest to thwart future terrorist activities.
Officials identified the man as Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi, who was captured by Pakistani officials as he tried to flee from Afghanistan. He was turned over to the American military in the last few days, an American official said.

Mr. Libi, a Libyan, is being held at a military detention center at the Kandahar airport and could soon be flown to the amphibious ship Bataan in the northern Arabian Sea, military officials said. The Bataan is holding eight other high-profile prisoners, including John Walker Lindh, the 20-year-old Californian found fighting with the Taliban.

Mr. Libi was responsible for paramilitary training at a bin Laden camp in Afghanistan known as Al Khaldan, one of Al Qaeda's largest.

The United States has also taken custody of the former Taliban ambassador to Pakistan, Mullah Abdul Salam Zaeef. He was flown to the Bataan today for questioning, and he will be detained there.

The two seizures represent a rare success in gaining control of senior Al Qaeda or Taliban leaders.

But American officials are expressing increasing confidence that they are homing in on terrorist leaders after interrogating thousands of Taliban and Al Qaeda prisoners, and recovering reams of documents and computer disks from terrorist safe houses across the country.

Military and other government investigators are interrogating a total of 307 Taliban and Al Qaeda prisoners at three sites in Afghanistan and on the Bataan. The first group of detainees is scheduled to be flown under heavy guard later this month to a secure jail being built at the United States Navy base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

''The information we have gotten has been very fruitful in many cases, and we think we have thwarted attacks, and has led to, if not arrests, to surveillance of terrorist leadership,'' Gen. Richard B. Myers, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said this week.

[In Berlin, German authorities said they arrested a suspected member of al Qaeda in a raid late on Saturday night at a central hotel in Moenchengladbach, near Duesseldorf, Reuters reported early Sunday. The unarmed man, who had an Italian name, was charged with membership in an illegal organization, the authorities said, adding that the police questioned a number of people in the same hotel.]

Mr. Libi, whose capture was first reported by NBC News on Friday evening, is a close associate of Abu Zubaydah, one of Mr. bin Laden's confidants. Mr. Zubaydah is believed to have taken over as Al Qaeda's top military strategist after the death of Muhammad Atef in an American airstrike in Afghanistan in November.

Federal and military investigators in Kandahar and aboard the Bataan are expected to question Mullah Zaeef and Mr. Libi, who was one of 12 Al Qaeda figures on the original list of individuals and organizations whose assets were frozen by President Bush on Sept. 26 in the aftermath of the attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.

Mullah Zaeef had become the international face of the Taliban in recent months through his defiant, televised news conferences. He was detained in Pakistan after his request for asylum was denied. Apparently out of political sensitivity, the Pakistanis did not state that the ambassador was being turned over to the Americans. Instead, a spokesman said, he was returned to Afghanistan because ''he didn't any longer have a valid visa to stay.''

The spokesman, Aziz Ahmed Khan, would not say when or where Mullah Zaeef crossed the border or who received him on the other side.

The spokesman's remarks were a sign of the delicate position of the Pakistani government as it joined the American-led campaign to crush an Islamic movement that Pakistan had helped to create, and which many Pakistanis supported.

Even though I linked the story, I used my account at the university (ez proxy) to get it. Just wanted something to be legit tonight, I guess.

All it takes to fly is to hurl yourself at the ground... and miss. (Douglas Adams)

by scoophound on 11/05/2005 09:02:32 PM EST

It seems there is a likely investigation of Blair.  The thought that occurred to me is that with GOP majorities in House and Senate perhaps a Blair investigation will be helpful in showing some of the illegal stuff Bushco has been up to on this side of the ocean.  Now comes this information!  It seems like there could be investigations going on in both places.  I am hoping that they will feed each other and this will become a volcano of information that is so hot that neither Bush nor Blair can keep the fires dampened down.  

It is about time!

Thank you.  

by macmcd on 11/06/2005 06:43:29 AM EST

 Display: