Sponsors

Did Dick Cheney think his victim would die? Email Print

DCDemocrat offers an interesting theory on why there might have been a delay in releasing information about Dick Cheney shooting a man and why the ranch owner served as the spokesman:

In the early hours after the accident, I am willing to bet that there was uncertainty about whether Cheney's victim might perish.  In that case, there would have been clear legal repercussions.  Any public statement might have furnished evidence in a legal action.  

When they concluded that Whittington's life was not in imminent danger, I am willing to bet that Cheney asked Ms. Armstrong to break the story so he would maintain plausible deniability concerning any statement made as a representation of the facts of the case.  Ms. Armstrong, after all, was not a legal representative of the Vice President nor even an official in the Vice President's office.

My bet this morning is that the PR strategy Cheney concocted was upon the advice of counsel.  It was less preoccupied with the political ramifications of the shooting than it was concerned about keeping Cheney out of legal jeopardy.  Whatever else that would suggest, it probably indicates that Mr. Whittington's medical situation was at the first far more ambiguous than we have been led to believe.


That also ties in with Cheney's statement that when he approached Whittington. From WaPo:

Q What did you think when you saw the injuries? How serious did they appear to you to be?

THE VICE PRESIDENT: I had no idea how serious it was going to be. I mean, it could have been extraordinarily serious. You just don't know at that moment. You know he's been struck, that there's a lot of shot that had hit him.

UPDATE: Glenn Greenwald seems to have similar thoughts:
I'm far from convinced that there was any great cover-up here, but clearly Cheney waited to notify the press and then waited much longer to talk about what happened because he did not know what the outcome would be and wanted time to construct his story and defense. The interview was replete with the sort of obfuscating and evasion that one routinely finds in an overly prepared and defensive deposition witness who is doing everything except testifying truthfully and clearly.


KEYWORDS:

Sign up for a Complimentary Member Account... Join the community! It's fast. And it'll allow you to take advantage of all this site's great features!

< Did Cheney Really Shoot Whittington? | Whittington Kept under Wraps in Intensive Care >
 Display:
Thank you for the props.  

by DCDemocrat on 02/16/2006 02:15:38 PM EST

while the 18 hour gap theory was tidal waving itself down the 'Cheney Drunk' ally, you came up with a legit alternative.

Impressive stuff!

Political Cortex -- Brain Food for the Body Politic

by Tom Ball on 02/16/2006 03:14:06 PM EST

[ Parent ]
I think this is the most likely reason, combined with the fear of a blood alcohol test.  Texas law doesn't require a blood alcohol test in case of a hunting accident (most other states do), however, in the case of an accidental death, a whole new set of regulations would kick in.

My take is that Cheney spent 18 hours sobering up and sacrificing goats in hopes of staying out of court.

by Devilstower on 02/16/2006 11:34:09 AM EST

hunting accidents are not required by Texas law to be reported to the police UNLESS they result in death.

Hospitals on the other hand, must report all hunting accidents.

With all Cheney's doctor's on hand, there is a good chance that they waited to take him to the hospital.

That would have created a timeline that is pushed later into the afternoon -- thus allowing his 'one beer' to seem like it was further in the distance -- implicitly having no effect on Cheney's judgement as he pulled the trigger.

Political Cortex -- Brain Food for the Body Politic

by Tom Ball on 02/16/2006 03:04:16 PM EST

[ Parent ]
it was to protect Dick.

Any time you shoot a 78-year-old man, it isn't a minor "incident."  I have no doubt it was an accident, but with Cheney's description of what he saw (the blood, the number of shots that hit him, the closed eye), he had to have thought this was going to be deadly serious.

Since the first 24-48 hours would have been critical to determine a prognosis, my guess is that they waited partly for this reason before releasing any public information from the White House or its press machine.

As usual, the whole thing stinks of bad judgment, incompetence, self-serving behavior, and CYA antics being overlaid with inept PR strategies.

Taxes shall be levied according to ability to pay. That is the only American principle. FDR

by btyarbro on 02/16/2006 01:04:21 PM EST

You think Cheney might be thinking of incidents like this
A Grand Blanc teen who shot and killed his friend in June faces a minimum of 3 years, 7 months in prison after pleading Tuesday to manslaughter and weapons charges.

Or maybe he was thinking of the numerous events chronicled here.

Tacoma teen pleaded guilty Monday to manslaughter... The owner of the gun was charged with criminally negligent homicide, reckless endangerment, and aggravated assault... Laurie Susan Higgins, 37, of Upward was arrested Thursday... Shearer was charged with second-degree assault, which carries a penalty ranging from one year in the county jail, or two to seven years in a state prison...

These charges -- and thousands more like them -- all resulted from accidental shootings.

by Devilstower on 02/16/2006 03:06:17 PM EST

various combinations of the terms 'hunter', 'accident', 'shooting', 'negligent homicide' etc. and found so many examples of people doing essentially what Cheney did and apying some sort fo price for it.

Add alcohol to the mix and then... well, you can imagine.

Political Cortex -- Brain Food for the Body Politic

by Tom Ball on 02/16/2006 03:17:35 PM EST

[ Parent ]
 Display: