Sponsors

Darwin's Nightmare Email Print

On the same morning, I can be both infuriated with my public radio station -- as when they parrot administration talking points on the port sale -- and tremendously grateful that they still get my $40.  This morning, I was grateful, because if it wasn't for NPR, I would have never heard about the film, Darwin's Nightmare, and I would have never learned this both fascinating and repellent story of people, exploitation, and a very hungry fish.

How weird is this story? Here's what so astonished filmmaker Hubert Sauper:

I witnessed... the bizarre juxtaposition of two gigantic airplanes, both bursting with food. The first cargo jet brought 45 tons of yellow peas from America to feed the refugees in the nearby UN camps. The second plane took off for the European Union, weighted with 50 tons of fresh fish.

The Two Worlds
In a previous story, I argued that Earth is really two worlds: the temperate and the tropical.  Because of factors that have more to do with environment than any intrinsic difference in peoples (nicely covered in Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs, and Steel), the people of the northern temperate zone came to dominate the globe and obtained a significant technological advantage over other regions.  In parts of the planet where they were able to reproduce their culture, these peoples drove out native populations and turned areas into variations on their home turf -- a planet full of New Englands, Nova Scotias, and New Zealands.

In other parts of the world, the crops and culture of temperate Europe could not so easily be grafted.  This is true of desert regions of the Middle East, of the most mountainous parts of Asia, and particularly true of tropical Africa.  The tropics became a second world, so dismissed from the thoughts of the temperate world that it might as well be located on the far side of the Moon.  Only the tropical world does serve one important purpose: it is exploited for its resources.

A Fish Story
The Nile Perch (Lates niloticus) is, as you would expect, native to African rivers and to several lakes of the African Rift Valley.  The fish has been widely exported as a game species.  If you happen to be fishing the Green River in western Kentucky and you hook into something that looks like a crappie grown to absurd size, you can thank the TVA, who brought in Nile Perch to live in the warm waters downstream from power plant cooling towers.

In Africa, one place where the fish was not native was Lake Victoria.  Local legend suggest that the fish was introduced by one man, pitching one fish into the lake on one afternoon.  However, that's more of a metaphor for how quickly the fish have come to dominate the lake.  

Some time in the 1960's, in the heart of Africa, a new animal was introduced into Lake Victoria as a little scientific experiment. The Nile Perch, a voracious predator, extinguished almost the entire stock of the native fish species.

Having displaced many native species, Nile Perch turned Lake Victoria into nearly a monospecific environment, especially when it comes to large fish.  So much so that the primary food or large Nile Perch in the lake is... small Nile Perch.

But there's a good side to this invader.  Nile Perch is much treasured for the large slabs of white filets it can produce.  This fish is well established in the food supply of both Europe and America.  Having a lake full of Nile Perch represents a valuable resource.  So naturally, it had to be exploited.

Once the extent of the fishery in Lake Victoria was realized, foreign companies displaced the local fisheries just as neatly as the perch had done in the competitors in the lake.  Locals did get some jobs catching, preparing, and packing the fish for overseas shipment.  There was only one problem: the price they could get for the fish in foreign markets was so high that locals couldn't afford it.

People are literally starving on the edge of plenty.  It's not that there's no food in the area, it's that the food is being exported to people who can pay more for it.  Then the UN and charitable organizations are paying to ship more food back to the region, usually much lower quality food with much less protein than what was shipped out.  But hey, the locals are allowed to eat the rotting fish heads and pick flesh from discarded bones.

And that's only the beginning of the nightmare.

The Prime African Import
The most amazing discovery that Sauper made was not that more food was being poured out of the region than in, it was the other cargo being ferried in by those huge planes: weapons.  The same planes that carried food to the refugee camps were also full of guns and artillery.

Where were the weapons going?  To local armies and guerilla groups -- the same forces that had driven people into the refugee camps in the first place.

I met the Russian pilots and we became "kamarads". But soon it turned out that the rescue planes with yellow peas also carried arms to the same destinations, so that the same refugees that were benefiting from the yellow peas could be shot at later during the nights.

In the mornings, my trembling camera saw in this stinking jungle destroyed camps and bodies.

Ever wonder why there always seems to be another "rebel group" springing up in the mountains or jungles of every tropical African nation?  Why can't they get a stable government?  Why is there always corruption?  Because, by God, we want it that way.

Any time an African country threatens to get on its feet, a rebellion miraculously appears.  A rebellion well stocked with weapons.  How this miracle occurs is simple enough: foreign companies play "angel" to the rebels, providing them with the tools they need to destabilize their countries.

Why? To ensure that the tropical world is there to act as a cupboard for the temperate world, and not competition.  The nations of the temperate world make sure that the tropical world is never organized toward raising its own people out of misery.  Instead, Europe, America, and the rest of the temperate world work to see that Africa in particular stays a land of despots and poverty, a land where a moderate bribe is enough to relieve temperate companies of any burdensome laws and a case of Kalashnikovs delivered to the right people will always get you access to resources you might otherwise have to buy at market value.

What would happen if Africa made sense, if it had stable democracies?  Then its resources would cost more.  The temperate world would see price increases that made it harder to live as if the tropical world wasn't there.  There would be serious movement in Africa to address the health disaster and provide widespread education.  A stable Africa would know it's own worth and realize that it held the resources the rest of the world could not live without.

Nobody wants that.

The Story in a Nutshell
As part of his documentary, Sauper focuses on the life of one young girl.  Beautiful and educated, the girl can speak enough English to communicate with the visiting pilots.  This opens to her the only job available, that of prostitute.  When the girl is then killed by one of her drunken clients, a quick bribe is enough to see that the guilty party escapes the country without prosecution.

That's Africa. That girl tells the story of a continent in her short, tragic life. We're working hard to see that it stays that way.


KEYWORDS: , , , , ,

Sign up for a Complimentary Member Account... Join the community! It's fast. And it'll allow you to take advantage of all this site's great features!

< Winning one in Indiana | Media Parrots >
 Display:
Is happening right now.  Did you notice?

These armed conflicts are the deadliest ones in history since the second World War. In the Eastern Congo alone, the casualties of war on each single day equal the number of deaths on September 11th in New York.

by Devilstower on 02/22/2006 12:00:10 PM EST

手机铃 2768; 铃声下 6733; 免费铃 2768; 免费铃 2768;下载 免费手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 和弦铃 2768; 三星铃 2768; 三星手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 MP3铃声 手机铃 2768;下载 手机自 2534;铃声 MP3手机铃 声 诺基亚 8083;声下๙ 3; NOKIA铃声ߍ 9;载 小灵通 8083;声下๙ 3; 真人铃 2768; MP3铃声下 载 自编铃 2768; 联通铃 2768;下载 移动手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 联通手 6426;铃声ࠡ 3;费下载 TCL铃声 飞利浦 8083;声下๙ 3; 特效铃 2768; 搞笑铃 2768; MIDI铃声 铃声图 9255; MMF铃声下 载 免费手 6426;图片ߍ 9;载 免费手 6426;点歌 手机短 0449; 手机彩 0449; 手机彩 8083; 康佳手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 TCL手机铃 声下载 迪比特 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;下载 手机和 6059;铃声 三星手 6426;铃声 三星手 6426;和弦໠ 3;声下载 波导手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 熊猫手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 免费手 6426;铃声 科健手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 海尔手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 诺基亚 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;下载 手机和 4358;铃声 手机铃 2768;图片ߍ 9;载 飞利浦 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;下载 手机自 2534;铃声ੋ 4;谱 小灵通 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;下载 手机铃 2768;编辑 CDMA手机铃 ;声下载 摩托罗 5289;手机໠ 3;声下载 联通CDMA手 ;机铃声&# 19979;载 松下手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 东信手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 联想手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 中兴手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 大显手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 首信手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 三星手 6426;自编໠ 3;声 三星CDMA手 ;机铃声 康佳手 6426;和弦໠ 3;声 MP3手机铃 声下载 索尼爱 1435;信手੒ 6;铃声 手机铃 2768;大全 三星手 6426;铃声ࢳ 0;片下载 手机特 5928;铃声 手机铃 2768;制作 三星手 6426;铃声ࠡ 3;费下载 TCL手机自 编铃声 松下手 6426;自编໠ 3;声 飞利浦 5163;机自ವ 4;铃声 诺基亚 5163;机自ವ 4;铃声 摩托罗 5289;自编໠ 3;声 三星手 6426;MP3铃声 手机MP3铃 声制作 6719;件 免费MP3铃 声下载 摩托罗 5289;MP3铃声 三星MP3铃 声下载 联通MP3铃 声下载 中国移 1160;铃声ߍ 9;载 中国联 6890;手机໠ 3;声下载 免费联 6890;手机໠ 3;声 联通铃 2768; 联通用 5143;手机໠ 3;声下载 联通手 6426;和弦໠ 3;声下载 联通手 6426;铃声ࢳ 0;片下载 小灵通 8083;声免ฟ 3;下载 和弦铃 2768;免费ߍ 9;载 免费下 6733;三星໠ 3;声 诺基亚 0813;费铃ࣤ 8;下载 联通免 6153;铃声ߍ 9;载 免费铃 2768;图片ߍ 9;载 MMF铃声免 费下载 TCL免费铃 声下载 免费下 6733;铃声 手机铃 2768;免费ߍ 9;载 松下免 6153;铃声ߍ 9;载 NOKIA免费໠ 3;声下载 MIDI铃声免 ;费下载 和弦铃 2768;下载 TCL免费手 机铃声 9979;载 免费手 6426;铃声ࢳ 0;片下载 免费手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载网站 小灵通 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;免费下& #36733; 诺基亚 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;免费下& #36733; 摩托罗 5289;手机໠ 3;声免费& #19979;载 三星和 4358;铃声 CECT和弦铃 ;声下载 三星T108和 ;弦铃声 NOKIA和弦໠ 3;声下载 康佳和 4358;铃声ߍ 9;载 迪比特 1644;弦铃ࣤ 8;下载 阿尔卡 9305;和弦໠ 3;声 CDMA和弦铃 ;声下载 夏新和 4358;铃声ߍ 9;载 西门子 1644;弦铃ࣤ 8; 诺基亚 1644;弦铃ࣤ 8; 联通和 4358;铃声 三星铃 2768;下载 三星和 6059;铃声 三星T108铃 ;声下载 三星手 6426;铃声ߔ 8;园 三星CDMA铃 ;声下载 三星免 6153;铃声 三星真 0154;铃声 诺基亚310 0铃声下&# 36733; NOKIA手机໠ 3;声下载 怎样下 6733;小灵๩ 0;铃声 真人铃 2768;下载 真人真 1809;手机໠ 3;声下载 联通用 5143;铃声ߍ 9;载 联通CDMA铃 ;声下载 TCL手机铃 声图片 9979;载 TCL手机和 弦铃声 9979;载 飞利浦630 铃声下 6733; 三星特 5928;铃声 手机特 5928;铃声ߍ 9;载 搞笑短 0449; MMF手机铃 声 MMF格式铃 声 免费短 0449; 短信笑 5805; 幽默短 0449; 经典短 0449; 谜语短 0449; 短信祝 1119; 爆笑短 0449; 生日短 0449; 爱情短 0449; 精彩短 0449; 情人节 0701;信 短信传 4773; 节日短 0449; 彩信图 9255; 彩信动 0011; 彩信相 0876; 免费彩 0449;下载 三星彩 0449; 联通彩 0449; 移动彩 0449; 彩信铃 2768; 免费彩 8083;下载 移动彩 8083; 联通彩 8083; 12530彩铃 小灵通 4425;铃 免费三 6143;手机໠ 3;声 免费和 4358;铃声 手机图 8083;下载 免费图 8083;下载 待机彩 2270; 三星手 6426;待机ঊ 5;图 丰胸铃 2768; 网络游 5103; 免费游 5103;下载 小游戏 在线游 5103; 游戏外 5346; 游戏论 2363; 游戏点 1345; 联众游 5103; 泡泡堂 8216;戏 游戏攻 0053; FLASH游戏 单机游 5103;下载 美女 美女图 9255; 美女写 0495; 美女论 2363; 性感美 2899; 美女走 0809; 街头走 0809; 走光照 9255; 免费电 4433;下载 免费在 2447;电影 免费电 4433;在线ෆ 6;看 小电影 免费成 0154;电影 免费激 4773;电影 电影论 2363; PP点点通& #30005;影下$ 733; BT电影下& #36733; 免费三 2423;电影 爱情电 4433; 舒淇电 4433; 韩国电 4433; 周星驰 0005;影 流行音 0048; 免费音 0048;下载 音乐在 2447; 在线音 0048; 古典音 0048; 音乐试 1548; MP3音乐 MP3下载 MP3播放器 MP3随身听 免费MP3歌 曲下载 QQ下载 申请QQ QQ幻想外& #25346; QQ表情 QQ挂机 珊瑚虫QQ QQ头像 QQ游戏 QQ空间代& #30721; QQ个性签& #21517; 网络小 5828; 玄幻小 5828; 成人小 5828; 爱情小 5828; 小说下 6733; 金庸小 5828; 武侠小 5828; 聊天室 语音聊 2825;室 列车时 1051;表 手机铃 2768; 铃声下 6733; 免费铃 2768; 免费铃 2768;下载 免费手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 和弦铃 2768; 三星铃 2768; 三星手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 MP3铃声 手机铃 2768;下载 手机自 2534;铃声 MP3手机铃 声 诺基亚 8083;声下๙ 3; NOKIA铃声ߍ 9;载 小灵通 8083;声下๙ 3; 真人铃 2768; MP3铃声下 载 自编铃 2768; 联通铃 2768;下载 移动手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 联通手 6426;铃声ࠡ 3;费下载 TCL铃声 飞利浦 8083;声下๙ 3; 特效铃 2768; 搞笑铃 2768; MIDI铃声 铃声图 9255; MMF铃声下 载 免费手 6426;图片ߍ 9;载 免费手 6426;点歌 手机短 0449; 手机彩 0449; 手机彩 8083; 康佳手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 TCL手机铃 声下载 迪比特 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;下载 手机和 6059;铃声 三星手 6426;铃声 三星手 6426;和弦໠ 3;声下载 波导手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 熊猫手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 免费手 6426;铃声 科健手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 海尔手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 诺基亚 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;下载 手机和 4358;铃声 手机铃 2768;图片ߍ 9;载 飞利浦 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;下载 手机自 2534;铃声ੋ 4;谱 小灵通 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;下载 手机铃 2768;编辑 CDMA手机铃 ;声下载 摩托罗 5289;手机໠ 3;声下载 联通CDMA手 ;机铃声&# 19979;载 松下手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 东信手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 联想手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 中兴手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 大显手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 首信手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载 三星手 6426;自编໠ 3;声 三星CDMA手 ;机铃声 康佳手 6426;和弦໠ 3;声 MP3手机铃 声下载 索尼爱 1435;信手੒ 6;铃声 手机铃 2768;大全 三星手 6426;铃声ࢳ 0;片下载 手机特 5928;铃声 手机铃 2768;制作 三星手 6426;铃声ࠡ 3;费下载 TCL手机自 编铃声 松下手 6426;自编໠ 3;声 飞利浦 5163;机自ವ 4;铃声 诺基亚 5163;机自ವ 4;铃声 摩托罗 5289;自编໠ 3;声 三星手 6426;MP3铃声 手机MP3铃 声制作 6719;件 免费MP3铃 声下载 摩托罗 5289;MP3铃声 三星MP3铃 声下载 联通MP3铃 声下载 中国移 1160;铃声ߍ 9;载 中国联 6890;手机໠ 3;声下载 免费联 6890;手机໠ 3;声 联通铃 2768; 联通用 5143;手机໠ 3;声下载 联通手 6426;和弦໠ 3;声下载 联通手 6426;铃声ࢳ 0;片下载 小灵通 8083;声免ฟ 3;下载 和弦铃 2768;免费ߍ 9;载 免费下 6733;三星໠ 3;声 诺基亚 0813;费铃ࣤ 8;下载 联通免 6153;铃声ߍ 9;载 免费铃 2768;图片ߍ 9;载 MMF铃声免 费下载 TCL免费铃 声下载 免费下 6733;铃声 手机铃 2768;免费ߍ 9;载 松下免 6153;铃声ߍ 9;载 NOKIA免费໠ 3;声下载 MIDI铃声免 ;费下载 和弦铃 2768;下载 TCL免费手 机铃声 9979;载 免费手 6426;铃声ࢳ 0;片下载 免费手 6426;铃声ߍ 9;载网站 小灵通 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;免费下& #36733; 诺基亚 5163;机铃ࣤ 8;免费下& #36733; 摩托罗 5289;手机໠ 3;声免费& #19979;载 三星和 4358;铃声 CECT和弦铃 ;声下载 三星T108和 ;弦铃声 NOKIA和弦໠ 3;声下载 康佳和 4358;铃声ߍ 9;载 迪比特 1644;弦铃ࣤ 8;下载 阿尔卡 9305;和弦໠ 3;声 CDMA和弦铃 ;声下载 夏新和 4358;铃声ߍ 9;载 西门子 1644;弦铃ࣤ 8; 诺基亚 1644;弦铃ࣤ 8; 联通和 4358;铃声 三星铃 2768;下载 三星和 6059;铃声 三星T108铃 ;声下载 三星手 6426;铃声ߔ 8;园 三星CDMA铃 ;声下载 三星免 6153;铃声 三星真 0154;铃声 诺基亚310 0铃声下&# 36733; NOKIA手机໠ 3;声下载 怎样下 6733;小灵๩ 0;铃声 真人铃 2768;下载 真人真 1809;手机໠ 3;声下载 联通用 5143;铃声ߍ 9;载 联通CDMA铃 ;声下载 TCL手机铃 声图片 9979;载 TCL手机和 弦铃声 9979;载 飞利浦630 铃声下 6733; 三星特 5928;铃声 手机特 5928;铃声ߍ 9;载 搞笑短 0449; MMF手机铃 声 MMF格式铃 声 免费短 0449; 短信笑 5805; 幽默短 0449; 经典短 0449; 谜语短 0449; 短信祝 1119; 爆笑短 0449; 生日短 0449; 爱情短 0449; 精彩短 0449; 情人节 0701;信 短信传 4773; 节日短 0449; 彩信图 9255; 彩信动 0011; 彩信相 0876; 免费彩 0449;下载 三星彩 0449; 联通彩 0449; 移动彩 0449; 彩信铃 2768; 免费彩 8083;下载 移动彩 8083; 联通彩 8083; 12530彩铃 小灵通 4425;铃 免费三 6143;手机໠ 3;声 免费和 4358;铃声 手机图 8083;下载 免费图 8083;下载 待机彩 2270; 三星手 6426;待机ঊ 5;图 丰胸铃 2768; 网络游 5103; 免费游 5103;下载 小游戏 在线游 5103; 游戏外 5346; 游戏论 2363; 游戏点 1345; 联众游 5103; 泡泡堂 8216;戏 游戏攻 0053; FLASH游戏 单机游 5103;下载 美女 美女图 9255; 美女写 0495; 美女论 2363; 性感美 2899; 美女走 0809; 街头走 0809; 走光照 9255; 免费电 4433;下载 免费在 2447;电影 免费电 4433;在线ෆ 6;看 小电影 免费成 0154;电影 免费激 4773;电影 电影论 2363; PP点点通& #30005;影下$ 733; BT电影下& #36733; 免费三 2423;电影 爱情电 4433; 舒淇电 4433; 韩国电 4433; 周星驰 0005;影 流行音 0048; 免费音 0048;下载 音乐在 2447; 在线音 0048; 古典音 0048; 音乐试 1548; MP3音乐 MP3下载 MP3播放器 MP3随身听 免费MP3歌 曲下载 QQ下载 申请QQ QQ幻想外& #25346; QQ表情 QQ挂机 珊瑚虫QQ QQ头像 QQ游戏 QQ空间代& #30721; QQ个性签& #21517; 网络小 5828; 玄幻小 5828; 成人小 5828; 爱情小 5828; 小说下 6733; 金庸小 5828; 武侠小 5828; 聊天室 语音聊 2825;室 列车时 1051;表

by awv5600 on 07/04/2006 10:02:28 AM EST

 Display: